Methos is my favourite, and am perfectly happy with him being the only Highlander character present. I'm also equally happy with any assortment of Highlander characters along with him.
I very much enjoy Gen, especially friendship fic, Het is great too, but M/M just doesn't do a thing for me, I'm afraid. Pairings, I don't have an OTP--I'm not all that shippy--but don't mind Methos/Amanda, or Methos/Rebecca, and Methos/OFC would be lovely, or some crossover pairing. I'd prefer no Cassandra or Alexa.
I love crossovers, and alternate universes, but a straight Highlander fic would be just as great. Highlander fic set in another universe works too, for example, a purely Highlander story set in the Star Trek future, but no Star Trek characters, that sort of thing. I enjoy stories where our Immies have to adapt to changing times - and that can be the future or the past. I also really enjoy a good historical piece, not limited to Tudor England, Norse/Vikings, Ancient Egypt, Celtic Britain, Arthurian, World War I and II and the years between, Colonial North America, Old West.
And speaking of crossovers, you're welcome to choose from any of my fandoms that speak to you - I'm easy :)
On Dreamwidth, this post has comments ~ feel free to comment on either journal.